The Way to Dusty Death

"I don't like sand. It's coarse and rough and irritating and it gets everywhere."

"Star Wars: Episode II: Attack of the Clones"

And another short comic post week!

Sharaku Homura: Detective of the Uncanny has been one of my favorite mystery manga ever since I discovered it in 2018. Manga artist Nemoto Shou has been self-publishing the comics for many years now, though major publisher Bungeishunju has also been releasing collected volumes of this comic digitally, making all the older issues available via the major e-book storefronts. In more recent years, Nemoto Shou has been releasing newer issues via his Note site and I have been discussing those releases here too. There's no fixed release schedule though, as he does these comics between other work, so it's a matter of a lot of patience, and checking his website often. 

And last week, he finally updated again with a new entry in this series: Kaiki Tantei Sharaku Homura: Sunazukin ("Sharaku Homura: Detective of the Uncanny - The Sand Hood", 2005) is just fifty pages long, which is basically a short story in this series (long stories can run closer to 150), so it's fairly simple in set-up. A novelist from a neighboring prefecture is visiting Shimoyama City, or to be more exact: he's visiting the sand dunes of Shimiyama City to gain inspiration for his new book, which includes a scene of a man crashing with a plane in the desert. The writer is staying at the nearest inn, and goes out pacing around the dunes to experience what it is to be lost in the desert. However, it's his life that gets lost there, as later that day, a man discovers the author lying dead among the sand dunes, his head smashed so hard he lost his teeth. However, for some reason the only footsteps near the poor man are of his own: his footsteps show how he had been wandering around in the dunes, and then started circling around in thought, and he himself now lies dead in the circle of his own footsteps. But where did the killer who hit him come from, and where did they go? One onlooker suggests it was the handiwork of the Sand Hood, a local ghoul, who is said to be the ghost of a monk who died in these dunes and then became a Sand Man-esque character. The police then get a mysterious phone call of someone calling themselves the Sand Hood, and they have souvenirs for the police: the author's missing hat (which he wore while he was hiking in the dunes), and a metal pipe which according to the Sand Dune the victim had used in an attempt to fight the Sand Hood. The police doesn't know how to solve this murder, so they call in the help of middle student Sharaku Homura, who asssisted by Karate Kid once again try to reveal what's beneath the uncanny exterior of this case.

Like so often in this series, we have a genuine impossible murder mystery on our hands, and this time, it's one of the 'no footprints in the snow' variant, or in this case, sand. We have seen other examples of that in this series, like in Semi-Otoko ("The Cicada Man") (one of my favorite reads of 2023!) and Hagoromo no Kijo ("The Ogress With the Robe of Feathers") (one of my favorite reads of 20219!). However, there is one major difference between those stories, which I consider masterpieces of the puzzle plot mystery comic genre, and Sunazukin, and that is length. This story is barely a third of the length of the previously mentioned stories, and that of course severely limits the scale of this tale.

And that is immediately apparent once Homura explains the trick behind how the murderer managed to hit the victim in the face without leaving their own footprints in the sand. While I suppose the reader could very well randomly guess the solution to this, it's a shame the actual clues Nemoto planted to allow the reader to logically deduce the solution are uncharacteristically sloppy: he's usually extremely good at doing visual clues for example, but here it just doesn't work, and what's worse, in-universe, Sharaku doesn't even have to logically deduce the solution herself, as it's basically handed to her on a platter by being at the right place at the right time by complete coincidence. Nemoto is generally great at making a satisfying build-up to the solution, showing exactly (with page references!) where all the visual hints were that would allow the reader to figure out the solution based on those clue, here that process is barely there.

However, I do have to say I really liked the supporting clues, that revolve around the Sand Hood taunting the police by giving them the victim's hat and the metal pipe. The visual clues here that show you how this is all connected to the grand picture are much better in comparison, and show glimpses of how good Nemoto can really plot mystery stories, though it is just a very small element of this story, so it only makes you wanting for more.

Considering Nemoto Shou has written some of my favorite "no footprints in the snow" mystery comics in the past, I can't help but feel a bit disappointed by Sunazukin, even if I could guess from the page count it would be a relative simple story. I wouldn't recommend this one as your first Sharaku Homura read, as Nemoto's written much better ones, but I guess it's alright considering the length and all, and I still like the auxiliary clue. But I do think Nemoto really shines with the longer stories, and while I understand those take a lot of time (and he offers them for free too), I hope we'll see one of those super long stories again this year.

Original Japanese title(s): 根本尚（札幌の六畳一間）「怪奇探偵 写楽炎　砂頭巾」