tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8031063966272508587.post4833225603157210868..comments2024-03-29T00:31:02.713+01:00Comments on ボクの事件簿: Captured in Her EyesHo-Linghttp://www.blogger.com/profile/04673330638260132388noreply@blogger.comBlogger5125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8031063966272508587.post-38059717059491702812011-08-01T09:14:48.100+02:002011-08-01T09:14:48.100+02:00『容疑者X』をめぐる争論はよう知っとうよ。それは確かに問題作やったね。ボクは一応本格だとは思うばって...『容疑者X』をめぐる争論はよう知っとうよ。それは確かに問題作やったね。ボクは一応本格だとは思うばってん、笠井や二階堂の主張が解らんわけではない。両氏は確かにいい点に付いとう。だが、『容疑者X』は本格かにたいしてYESかNOかと聞かれたら、ボクはやっぱYESで答える。<br /><br />購入の話に変わるばってん、確かにネット注文するとき、ボクも(ボクなりに)予習はちょっとやるよ。ネット注文の値段高かし、時間もかかるけん、やっぱいいもん注文したい。まぁ、実は今年ほとんど何も買わんかったばってん。積ん読が多すぎるけん >_>Ho-Linghttps://www.blogger.com/profile/04673330638260132388noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8031063966272508587.post-90632035633307118002011-08-01T00:26:18.970+02:002011-08-01T00:26:18.970+02:00そう言えば、東野圭吾の「容疑者Xの献身」も所謂問題作の一つ。本格かどうかという問題を巡って、論争とい...そう言えば、東野圭吾の「容疑者Xの献身」も所謂問題作の一つ。本格かどうかという問題を巡って、論争というほどまで話題になった。例えば笠井潔は「探偵小説は「セカイ」と遭遇した」の三分の一に「容疑者Xの献身」について評論してる。特に二階堂黎人は東野の作品を強く批判したようだ。其々のランキングに1位を獲得して、第6回本格ミステリ大賞を受けたのに...いや、多分だからこそそうせざるお得なかったのかも。まぁ、俺の雑誌を読んでも二階堂氏はどうせかなり厳しいな方だとは解ってくるけどな(汗)mousoukyokuhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/00755066580829504834noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8031063966272508587.post-26938178069039251122011-07-31T23:22:54.603+02:002011-07-31T23:22:54.603+02:00まっ、法月氏のはあまり問題作とは言えぬが、日本推理作家協会賞受賞作は幾つか話題になったと読んだ覚えは...まっ、法月氏のはあまり問題作とは言えぬが、日本推理作家協会賞受賞作は幾つか話題になったと読んだ覚えはある。今回の麻耶氏の受賞作もそうだ。それにメフィスト賞受賞作は時々問題作ばっかという印象もある(笑)良くもも悪くもな。俺には問題になるのは大体「本格かどうか」という意味に見える。若しくは「登場人物、設定、論理には現実味があるかどうか」ってな。<br /><br />The only 2 short times I've been to Japan were when I was not able to read Japanese novels yet... So now I mostly order stuff from amazon, which is so expensive that I always have to be somewhat sure that what I'm spending money on is at least worth it, if not awesome. I do occasionally find novels by e.g. Arisugawa Arisu in the Used section of the main Japanese bookstore in Düsseldorf though, which still isn't as cheap as Book-Off but definitely a lot more affordable than buying new goods.mousoukyokuhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/00755066580829504834noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8031063966272508587.post-39264607431069846182011-07-31T22:06:12.723+02:002011-07-31T22:06:12.723+02:00『生首・・・』は別に問題作やないと思うけどな。後半、特に結末はほんとによかとボクも認める (受賞すべ...『生首・・・』は別に問題作やないと思うけどな。後半、特に結末はほんとによかとボクも認める (受賞すべきだったのかはまた別の問題やけど)。 『生首・・・』に問題があるのは多分ボクだけやろ。やっぱ話にホトケさん出ないとあまり盛り上がらんタイプやけん。芸術にもあまり関心持っとらんし。<br /><br />I actually practically <i>never</i> look at any rankings at all. I only discovered this novel won a price <i>after</i> I had bought it. Actually, almost 6 months after I purchased it. The only novels I know won a price when I bought them, are the ones in the <i>Mystery Writers of Japan Award</i> series (with the black covers) (and that's more because they have to have won prices to be released in that series).<br /><br />Seriously, my purchasing habits in Japan are literally as follows: enter Book-Off, go to the 105 yen corner, look at names I know I have seen somewhere, buy random amount of books w/o even reading what's on the back. It's only when I want to write reviews that I do background research ^_~ (Thus explaining the inconsistent quality of the books I review here, as well as why I seem to stick to a select group of writers)Ho-Linghttps://www.blogger.com/profile/04673330638260132388noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8031063966272508587.post-41628804342240039112011-07-31T17:28:50.078+02:002011-07-31T17:28:50.078+02:00Sometimes the award winners are actually 問題作 and r...Sometimes the award winners are actually 問題作 and receive very diverging reviews for being so unique and experimental (for the better or the worse). That's why I always look at content descriptions, since books I've really liked a lot that won any award or ranked 1st in one of the mystery rankings are few in number. Many were featured somewhere in the Best 10 or 5 though. And the Mephisto Award Winners don't count as the criteria seem rather arbitrary to me...<br /><br />The current novel by Maya Yutaka I'm reading right now won the Japan Mystery Writers Association Award, the Orthodox Mystery Award and ranked 1st in 2011's Orthodox Mystery Best, so I'm curious how this one will turn out in the end since it's also one of those novels where opinions mostly diverge into absolute appraisal or disapproval.mousoukyokuhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/00755066580829504834noreply@blogger.com