Sunday, June 11, 2017

The Crooked Hinge

潮風にゆれる髪も大好きだったけど、
ただ何となくそうよ何となく髪を短くしたのよ
あなたのせいじゃないわ
少しだけセシルの気持ちがわかったの
「セシルカット」(戸川純)

I did love how my hair dance in the sea breeze,
But for some reason, just for no reason, I cut my hair short
It isn't because of you
But I think I understand how Cecile must've felt a little
"Cecil Cut" (Togawa Jun)

Trick was a surprise hit TV drama franchise which ran from 2000 until 2014. The quirky show took on the form of a classic mystery show featuring a detecting duo of a magician and a physicist solving impossible crimes and 'supernatural' phenomena in remote villages and communities, but it was in fact a playground for everyone involved: each story was packed full with visual jokes, wordplay, parody references; the characters were all over-the-top with outrageous character tics (it was obvious every actor was just having the time of their lives hamming every line up) and even the camera would go for the weirdest angles just to surprise the viewer. The show started out as a late-night low-key TV drama, but grew out to a major franchise with four theatrical releases, and the two leads, Nakama Yukie and Abe Hiroshi are now two of the biggest acting names in Japan.

A spin-off series starring supporting character Yabe Kenzou was produced in 2010 to coincide with the release of the third theatrical film Trick 3: Psychic Battle Royale. Yabe is an incompetent police detective (wearing a very obvious wig) who'd rather not exert himself protecing the people, and he often spends his time (secretly) looking for ways to grow his hair back. He worked wonderfully as the butt of the jokes in Trick, as the useless cop who sometimes worked against, and sometimes with the two leads while they were trying to solve the case. Even in his own series, Yabe managed to do no detecting himself, as other characters usually solved his problems for him, but through miraculous luck Yabe always got the credit for all those cases, making him one of the more infamous detectives of the Metropolitan Police Department. A second spin-off series was broadcast in 2013, about six months before the final Trick film.

As Trick - Last Stage marked the end of the franchise in 2014, you can imagine how surprised I was to learn that a new Yabe Kenzou spin-off serie would be released in 2017! Keibuho Yabe Kenzou ~Jinkou Zunou VS Jinkou Zumou~ ("Lieutenant Yabe Kenzou ~ Artificial Brain VS Artificial Hair~") is a mini-series produced for online streaming, and burdens our fake-haired detective with a final assignment. Professor Deep Manabu is the creator of the highly efficient crime-fighting AI "God Eye Joe", which has been able to solve cases even faster than the FBI and Scotland Yard. Deep Manabu and God Eye Joe now intend to show the Japanese police force who is superior, and the case chosen for that end is that of the Dark Gyouji: A mysterious serial killer called the Dark Gyouji (as they're dressed as a sumo referee) is on the loose in the country, but they were last spotted near a secluded hot spring resort. Deep Manabu and God Eye Joe head for the place in order to solve the crime, but the Japanese police force can't just sit and watch, so they send Yabe Kenzou to solve the case for them. A landslide shuts the place off from the outside world, locking everyone in together with the Dark Gyouji. Can Yabe and his artificial hair beat the artificial brain?


So it was over three years since the last Trick production, but on the whole, this mini-series was exactly what'd the viewers have come to expect from the franchise in terms of presention. The familiar musical cues, the quick camera-work is all there, as well as the crazy characters, their snappy dialogue filled with wordplay and of course many references to earlier works. While the two leads of the main Trick series don't appear in person, there are some references to them, enforcing the idea that this is part of the main franchise. The three year blank did not change the feel of the series, luckily.

The main Trick series was always busy parodying the mystery fiction as written by Yokomizo Seishi, with serial murders taking place in secluded communities like cults or out-of-the-way villages. It fitted perfectly with the quirky comedy, as it allowed for characters with weird customs etcetera. The two original Yabe Kenzou series on the other hand were a parody on police series and took place in the metropolis that is Tokyo. Yabe would be facing international terrorists, spies and other big criminals, as opposed to the faux psychics that occupied the main Trick series. Keibuho Yabe Kenzou ~Jinkou Zunou VS Jinkou Zumou~'s setting of a secluded hot spring inn and a serial killer dressed like a sumo referee therefore fits the main series better than the Yabe Kenzou spin-off series in my mind, but oh well.


But despite the classic setting I have to say that story-wise, ~Jinkou Zunou VS Jinkou Zumou~ was disappointing. While Trick always did take on a parody-form, the titular "tricks" used in the mystery plots were actually always interesting, leading to engaging detective stories. The mystery plot of ~Jinkou Zunou VS Jinkou Zumou~ on the other hand is almost horribly simple. I'm afraid that this is because of the format. ~Jinkou Zunou VS Jinkou Zumou~ is a five-part streaming series, with each episode about fifteen minutes long. This means the total series is only slightly longer than any given single episode of the main Trick series or previous Yabe Kenzou spin-off series. Stories in Trick were usually two- or three-parters, so comparing them in terms of complexity might not be fair, but even the episodes in the previous two Yabe Kenzou series had more engaging mystery plots than ~Jinkou Zunou VS Jinkou Zumou~, and they were shorter! The problem is that because of the five-part set-up, each part needs to have its own mini-storyline that builds up to a climax. But they simply stretched a very basic mystery plot out, adding in uninspired 'cliffhangers' for each part and called it a day. The result: a story that overstays its welcome. The hinting is also quite horrible, and not at all like anything we'd seen earlier in the series.

What made the original Trick franchise so entertaining was that while everything involved was just fooling around in order to make it a great parody, the core was always built around solid mystery plots. If the parody elements had been taken away, you'd still have a solid mystery story. That was also true (up to an extent) for the prevous two Yabe Kenzou spin-off series, even if they focused more on parodying the police procedural. Keibuho Yabe Kenzou ~Jinkou Zunou VS Jinkou Zumou~ however has little to offer besides the comedy-coat, as the mystery plot is probably the worst of the whole series. So while I did laugh while watching the show, I don't know whether it was really worth it to produce such a series three years after the great ending that was Trick - Last Stage. If it had been a companion series to something else, okay, perhaps I could've appreciated it better, but as it is now, we just got a mediocre addition after the fact that adds nothing of unique interest.

Original Japanese title(s): 『警部補 矢部謙三〜人工頭脳VS人工頭毛〜』

8 comments :

  1. Has there been an anime series based on trick? Is trick better than kindaichi case files?and why dont you write reviews on kindaichi anymore?
    Any idea on indian detective fiction?your articles are based on european detective fiction & japanese detective fiction?if you have any idea on indian detective fiction then please suggest a title

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have nothing to review for the Kindaichi Case Files. I have mentioned it in every single review the last few years, but I only review the new series, and only when a story is complete. There's no complete story out at the moment that I haven't reviewed yet. If you really need a Kindaichi Case Files fix, I recommend visiting to TomCat's Beneath the Stains of Time, as he's been reviewing some select stories from the R anime the last few weeks.

      And I know absolutely nothing about Indian detective fiction, so you'll have to find someone else for that

      Delete
  2. emile gaborio was the one who wrote the first detective fiction.have you read any of his novels?

    ReplyDelete
  3. And by the way when will detective conan end?seems like aoyoma is making the manga boring.do you think he should finish the manga within the next 6 volumes or so?are you satisfied with his progress so far?the mystery surrounding the black organisation boss hasnt been resolved.who do you think is the boss?shed some light please

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have no idea when Conan will end. Several years ago, Aoyama mentioned wanting to end it near the 100, but we've come rather close to that now...

      (Oh, and please try to write everything in one comment, instead of splitting it in several comments: it kinda clutters the page).

      Delete
  4. Yeah, I was also quite surprised when they announced a new Yabe Kenzou thing, since it felt a bit out of the blue. I've always been meaning to watch the other two series, but I never seem to get around to it. I did watch an episode or two of the first one, but it felt a bit unsubstantial? Well, I appreciated the parodical elements anyway.

    Also, just before I read this post, I found out that Trick was indeed parodying Yokomizo Seishi's works, and so when I saw your mentioning of that, it was super validating. Things like Gokumontou/Kokumontou and their similar names/backstories and the Village of Eight/Six Graves. Now I want to go read them so I can see what was being parodied and all. If you don't mind answering, what were the other novels that were parodied in Trick?

    (Also, as a huge Trick fan, I'd just like to low-key appreciate all your great posts on Trick <3)
    (Actually tbh, I love that you post your thoughts on a lot of Japanese detective fiction - it's really great to see someone covering that lesser addressed side of things)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I wasn't a big fan of the two detective characters in the first Yabe series (the traffic (?) cop and the office worker). The second series was somewhat better. There's also a hilarious Kamen Rider running joke in the second series, with all the guest police detective characters being played by former Kamen Rider actors (and named after their KR roles).

      The Trick 3 episodes about the poet family was basically one big Yokomizo world parody. Trick Specials 2 and 3 are also obvious Yokomizo parodies: the second special was obviously inspired by Akuma no Temariuta, while the third special is more-or-less a straight parody of Inugamike no Ichizoku/The Inugami Clan, with some of the scenes almost 1:1 copied from the Ichikawa Kon films (the opening for example, or the reading of the will).

      Last week brought the sad news that the actress of Yamada's mother passed away, which makes it unlikely new (main) Trick productions will ever come again though.

      Delete